DirecTV gets favorable Supreme Court ruling; California class-actioners can only do private arbitration

Signaling a major legal win for DirecTV (NYSE: T), or any other corporation operating in California, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that a class-action suit against the pay-TV operator can't move forward because the complaints must be settled in private arbitration. 

In a 6-3 ruling, the high court determined that DirecTV's contract, which forbids class-action suits and calls for disputes to be settled through arbitration, is valid. 

"The ruling affirms the strong federal policy favoring arbitration agreements that efficiently allow consumers and businesses to resolve disputes without further burdening our overloaded courts," DirectTV said in a statement to FierceCable.

The class-action suit was over early-termination fees.

The court agreed to hear the case after a California appeals state court ruled that a clause in the satellite operator's subscriber contract made arbitration unenforceable. Subsequently, the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco ruled that DirecTV could move forward with arbitration. 

Justice Stephen G. Breyer disented in a 2011 Supreme Court decision in AT&T v. Concepcion, a case that ruled that state laws protecting class-action suits in arbitration were preempted by federal law.

But regrading Monday's ruling, he wrote, "The fact that Concepcion was a closely divided case, resulting in a decision from which four justices dissented" has no bearing on the obligation of lower courts to follow its holding.

For more:
- read this Washington Post story
- read this Seeking Alpha report
- read this Law 360 story

Related articles:
FTC slams DirecTV's bid to pare down false-advertising suit as case goes to trial
Better Business Bureau urges DirectTV to change or ditch 4K ad
DirecTV class action suit over early termination fees reaches Supreme Court

Suggested Articles

CuriosityStream, a subscription video service specializing in science and nature series and films, said it now has 10.5 million paying subscribers.

AT&T plans to launch HBO Max in May 2020, and the company is still working on deals with traditional pay TV distributors that sell HBO.

Charter CEO Tom Rutledge has long been a big proponent of strong content security, and now he’s calling out simultaneous streams on SVODs.