Rep. Pallone: Wheeler’s new set-top plan ‘won’t work’

Representative Frank Pallone (D-N.J.) | Image: Ryan Kelly/Getty Images

Rep. Frank Pallone (D-N.J.), who has been an ally to the pay-TV industry in its battle to stop the FCC from regulating leased set-top boxes, has come out against a revised proposal by agency Chairman Tom Wheeler. 

“While I commend Chairman Wheeler for working to solve this difficult issue, I’m concerned that this latest proposal will not work, particularly when it comes to licensing,” said Pallone, the top Democrat on the Energy and Commerce Committee, in a statement. “Ultimately, I’m skeptical that the revised plan will benefit consumers.”

Last week, Wheeler put forth a major revision of his “Unlock the Box” proposal, which sought to engage devices from third-party manufacturers like Google, Amazon and TiVo in the pay-TV ecosystem. The goal was to disrupt what critics described as near monopoly power by pay-TV operators to force customers to lease their set-tops. 

Sponsored by Google Cloud

Webinar: Remote Post Production In The Cloud

Video production companies across the world have traditionally been tethered to physical facilities, but with the advent of covid-19, remote post production capabilities are more important than ever. Join this webinar to learn more about how video producers can utilize Google Cloud infrastructure, along with partner applications, to develop a remote post production suite that brings your artists and editors together, no matter where they are.

Wheeler’s new plan is based on a counter-proposal, depending on multi-screen apps, championed by the National Cable Telecommunications Associations. But neither the NCTA, nor any of the constituencies who backed the lobbying group’s “Ditch the Box” counter-proposal, seem happy with Wheeler’s compromise. 

“Congressman Pallone’s skepticism about the FCC’s revised set-top box proposal could unfortunately cost consumers tens of billions of dollars in inflated cable charges,” said progressive group Public Knowledge, in a statement responding to Pallone. 

“Each cable household is currently getting ripped off by more than $20 a month in bogus set-top box fees,” Public Knowledge added. “We believe consumers will get the benefit of lower prices, more choices, and more innovation with the FCC’s plan and urge Congressman Pallone to re-evaluate his stance on this important consumer pocketbook issue.”

For more:
- read this Morning Consult story
- see the Public Knowledge statement

Related articles:
FCC's O’Rielly: New set-top plan ‘exists within a fantasy world of unlimited commission authority’
Wheeler formally pitches revised app-based set-top proposal, includes integrated search
Comcast, Charter, AT&T lament app-based set-top proposal they lobbied for, call it regulatory over-reach

Read more on

Suggested Articles

Virtual MVPD fuboTV posted a net loss of $99.8 million during the second quarter as its subscriber count held mostly steady.

After second-quarter video subscriber losses were better than feared, UBS has adjusted its cord-cutting estimate for 2020.

Redbox said Tastemade and Cheddar are now live on its free, live TV service, which now has more than 60 channels.